My criminal caseload ranges from misdemeanors to serious felonies, and includes DUI cases, theft cases, drug cases, robberies and murders. I have also successfully represented clients in complex Federal Cases as well as expungement of criminal records. I know that your case is incredibly important to you, and weighs on you every day. I am ready to help, no matter what the charge.
I get asked a lot of questions about what an Expungement Attorney
does and if they can help someone with a tarnished legal record. A few
of the more common questions are below. Please feel free to use this
information as a starting guide, but contact me with the specifics of
your case so I can help determine your best options.
What exactly is expungement of one's criminal records?
This
is process whereby your adult records are cleaned up of some of the
various criminal records associated with your legal history, when
reviewed in background checks by others. Although the phrase
'expungement of criminal records' does appear to sound all-encompassing,
there are certain details one has to keep in mind. The level of crime,
the details of your particular case, and other factors. Generally,
getting a conviction expunged from your record means that you are able
to hide the conviction from certain entities -- like some employers,
credit agencies, and even landlords in the event that a background check
is inititiated on you.
Will this assist me in getting employment, even with a record?
A
majority of the employers in the private sector are actually not
permitted to view a conviction that has been expunged -- and most
private employers are not permitted to ask you about a conviction that
has been expunged when applying for employment. This can be of great
benefit to someone trying to restart their life and entering the working
world.
Who exactly can receive an expungement of their criminal record?
Although
there is a certain number of crimes for which expungement is not
available, many crimes fall in the category which allows for
expungement. I can help you determine if the activity involving your
case is applicable, and if you are able to seek expungement, will assist
in that process. Will there be a hearing or court appearance?
Actually
this depends. In most misdemeanor cases, expungements are taken care
of without any actual hearing in a court. A determination will be made
based on filed documentation and a court order is made based on evidence
in theses documents. In the case of felony cases, we can represent you
in any court proceedings and you likely will not need to be present in
court as part of the process. We can discuss the options in your
particular case that suits you best.
Are there some things that an expungement will not do?
Yes.
As an example, expungements will not be removed from official FBI
criminal records or California conviction records. Depending on the
circumstances, possession of firearms may still be limited if taken away in such cases as domestic violence. There are
numerous details involving each case that determine what the expungement
in your particular case will remove. We can determine the details based
on your individual case.
The beating of Rihanna by Chris Brown sent the media into overdrive as the singer was not only caught in the spotlight by the media, but there were damning photos of the abuse which only made matters worse. It as no longer just a story, but a very vivid and visual event to the public. Reporting on such things said by Brown as "Now I'm really gonna kill you!" and other details, tabloids took the littlest details and put them in the spotlight for all to see.
The story becomes the most talked about story on social media for months. Chris Brown is charged with felony assault. Brown did not want the spectacle of Rihanna having to come to court to testify, so pleaded guilty, and received 480 hours of community service and three years of felony probation, along with anger-management classes.
As an apparent lack of remorse starts hurt his image after months of not apologizing or speaking to the issue, and album sales slump as radio stations refuse to play his music. Big sponsors like Wrigley's Gum drop him from their marketing plans, and even Sesame Street pulls the episode featuring the rapper.
Brown attempts to apologize to the public through a YouTube video, and it is not well-received by those who watched it, appearing to be forced and unapologetic in tone. In hindsight, it can be seen as doing too little, and much too late.
When Reese Witherspoon was caught getting arrested on a dashcam of a patrolman's car, the glimpse of the actress was less than flattering, and it led to a press onslaught of the A-list actress which only the star herself could finally come to terms with... and she eventually did.
Celebrities used to have the advantage of privacy in their everyday affairs, but with the proliferation of cameras and media in the world today, there are countless opportunities to catch someone acting up or misbehaving, and it usually tends to find its way into the public domain.
Witherspoon's husband is pulled over for driving drunk and Reese is the passenger in the car. She is caught on tape being rude to a police officer and obstructing the arrest of her husband, and her arrogant behavior becomes the talk of tweets, blogs and the news programs all over television. She was not prepared for 24/7 scrutiny, and the dashcam video proved to diminish her celebrity persona in the public eye.
A public apology given approximately two weeks later appeared to soften the blow to her career as she took responsibility for her behavior and gave a heartfelt apology for her attitude during the arrest. The way in which she handled this matter was hailed by many as a textbook example of how to do it right -- appearing to be both genuine and forthright.
Amanda Bynes who got her start as a Nickelodeon kid's television star, is arrested by the Police for drug possession and reckless endangerment. As the press goes after her and the story, she decides to use the internet and her Twitter account to attempt to tell her side of the story. Unfortunately, the manner in which some of it was done only raised more questions than it answered.
"I was sexually harassed... he slapped my vagina" was one such charge leveled at the Police that stirred the public.
As time progresses, the comments and online conversations Bynes is having with fans and the public at large become more and more strange. As the public learns more, they realize that it is not just the arrest they are finding out about, but a celebrity's private troubles. The shift in public attitude went from curiosity about a celebrity to actual concern for her health.
After an arrest for starting a fire on a random neighbor's driveway, Bynes was put on a 72-hour psychiatric hold. It turns out this incident was the breakthrough for her finally getting help for her bi-polar disorder and schizophrenia, and was a window into a celebrity's life that the public had never seen before.
Few scandals are able to grab the big headlines as a celebrity arrest, and one case in point is the arrest of Paul Reubens, or as you probably know him as better, "Pee Wee Herman". As a children's television superstar, being found masturbating in an adult theater could have not come as worse news to his career in Hollywood. The newspapers and television talk shows used the incident as fodder for jokes and stories, and it came at the expense of his career in children's entertainment.
As Reubens put it, "I turned on the TV and saw people I mistakenly thought were my friends making jokes about me."
When your entire career is children's entertainment, it could be easily said that taking out your private parts in an adult theater is not a good career move. And the press was relentless in their pursuit of this story. It even topped headlines of Jeffrey Dahmer, mass murderer, and somehow became the lead story. CBS immediately stopped airing Reuben's show, Pee Wee's Playhouse, merchandise was pulled from Toys R Us's shelves, and even Disney edited out his appearance in a ride at the MGM Themepark. The effect on his career was dramatic.
Pleading no contest, Paul Reubens settled his case in court without being able to proclaim his innocence, but even then, the tools of the media were only just beginning to set their sights on celebrities and their brushes with the law in a new and more powerful medium - the internet.
The Los Angeles Police Department was engaged in a prostitution sting in Hollywood, and as it turns out, they were going to catch one of it's newest actors in the act with a prostitute, and what happened next would alter how many celebrities choose to deal with fame and run-ins with the law. Hugh Grant was caught in a sexually compromising position with a prostitute, Divine Brown, and when the press caught wind of it, the news went wild.
With up to 6 months in jail possible, instead of hiding away and hoping it would fade from view with time, Hugh Grant faced the story head on. Instead of avoiding the cameras, he continued public appearances, including The Tonight Show, where he used the limelight to express his contrition and shame to the public at large. It was a game changer.
When it comes to what happens in a man's brain when sex is involved, no one can say for sure, but people who heard of the story were unable to understand why he would do something so reckless with a successful life, career and girlfriend at his side. However, by facing the problem directly, and without shying away from it, Grant was able to manage his way past this major episode in his life and continue on with only a small blemish to his name. Truly a new chapter in celebrity justice was written.
What started as a slow-speed pursuit on a Los Angeles freeway, ended up going down in the history books, as O.J. Simpson's trial forever changed the landscape of media and the judicial system in America. Simpson went on trial for the murder of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend, Ron Goldman.
What the trial turned into is by many accounts a media circus, and not just nationally but internationally, as all of the eyes of the world were on the Los Angeles courtroom where the fate of the ex-sports hero lay in the hands of a jury. As television cameras were allowed in the courtroom, the trial becomes a day-to-day drama of must-see TV that plays out across the world, and played out for more than eight months.
The presence of TV cameras in the courtroom meant that lawyers were really talking to two audiences when they were speaking - the court, and the court of public opinion.
Lindsay Lohan's misbehavior has lead in some regards to her ability to stay in the limelight and maintain her celebrity status, despite run-ins with law enforcement. Having been sent to a Los Angeles County jail six times on charges ranging from drunk driving, to parole violation, and even theft, Lohan became a fixture in the news at her various court appearances and public functions.
I at one point joke that Lohan could be seen as a defense lawyer's dream -- she's literally a repeat customer. But getting into trouble repeatedly can have a huge impact on one's status in the entertainment business, and how the public views you, so this extensive negative publicity eventually can take a big toll on one's ability to work, maintain a public image and live a normal celebrity life.
In one particular court appearance, it looks like Lohan used the extensive media presence to try and send a message to the world at large, when it was discovered she had written on her nails a small message of F**k..U, and whether it was aimed at the judge, her situation, or the world at large, it became another instance where a story blows up in the media, and her celebrity attention grows online and in the press.
The writing on her nails came across as projecting disrespect to the person who was sentencing Lohan, the judge, and was found by many to be wreckless and stupid. The line between the public and private lives of celebrities is blurred as people such as Lohan then take to social media to engage on their acts, defiant or otherwise, to project the image they want to create directly to the public.
When Martha Stewart's name hit the headlines in an investment scandal, the gossip blogs and online celebrity commentators jumped at the opportunity to pile on. Martha Stewart, it was discovered, had invested in ImClone shares after her broker's assistant called her with favorable information about a potential future drop in stock she owned. She ended up selling the stock, saving herself a grand total of $50,000.00 in the deal.
But the Securities and Exchange Commission was tipped off to her trade and began investigating her for insider trading. When brought in for questioning, Martha and her broker gave false statements to Federal authorities, and it was these false statements, apparently made to cover up the earlier deed, that was actually seen as worse in the public eye. Bloggers jumped at the chance to go after Stewart.
Martha Stewart is eventually convicted and has to relinquish control of her multi-billion dollar empire as she entered Federal prison in West Virginia. Stewart was sentenced to five months of prison and five months of house arrest, but she somehow managed to make the most of the sentencing.
In the end, her determination to weather the storm appeared to provide a bridge to her company's future, and it continues now as a strong corporate success story, despite the insider trading charges and false statements to authorities -- and even her prison time.
It has been determined by the California Supreme Court that computer sweepstakes games can be classified as illegal slot machines. The ruling raises a host of legal issues for companies that may rely on similar devices or games in their traditional sweepstakes marketing campaigns.
Justice Ming Chin found that despite the fact that games in question do not resemble outwardly what one might consider traditional slot machines or "one-armed bandits", the machines in question operated in such a way as to cross the line into prohibited hardware.
In such games as "Buck Lucky" and "Baby Bucks", it was determined that these games fell into the realm of gambling because players cannot use skill or judgment to influence the outcome of the games. In addition, Chin noted that the games are designed to cultivate the impression that the user may receive a reward by reason of any element of hazard or chance.
As I mentioned in the article covering this topic, I think this opinion opens up a Pandora's Box, and indeed it is going to be very difficult for corporations to run any kind of promotion
where the result is revealed on a computer.
The fact that his ruling could definitely affect promotional
sweepstakes operated by companies such as Coca-Cola and McDonalds was noted by Chin but he indicated that such questions would have to be decided in a case in
which someone claims some other sweepstakes system is an illegal slot
machine.
To read further about the case in The Recorder, click here.
Sean "Diddy" Combs, commenting via a representative, indicated that the altercation he was arrested for involving a coach at UCLA was the result of self-defense.
Combs was eventually charged with assault with a deadly weapon, and released on bail. The Combs team indicated they believed the case would be dismissed after the details surrounding the incident become apparent.
Their official response, released by a Combs representative, included the following:
"…any actions taken by Mr. Combs were solely defensive in nature to protect himself and his son."
As I note in the video, it sounds like an enraged or angry father, for whatever reason, confronted a coach, and during that confrontation, it got physical. Depending on what occurred, it could be absolutely nothing or it could be almost a felony.
When you're looking at a self defense situation, you look at the past and you look at everybody's whole life and how they react in certain situations, and you make a decision.
As noted in the video by reporter Patrick Healy, a filing decision may be made within a week or two from the incident, and if the District Attorney passes as a felony, it could go then to the City Attorney as a misdemeanor.
Recent shootings in Southern California, both in Santa Monica and Santa Barbara, return the subject of guns and gun violence to the headlines. It often seems that the divide over the gun issue is growing wider, and that reasonable people on both sides have a sense of frustration that their views are often demonized by the other side.
When responding to the questions put to me for a PBS story on gun violence, I had to take a step back and truly evaluate the issues in the story before jumping to any previously held conclusions. Sometimes one has to take a breath and step back in perspective to give a reasonable thought or two on the issue at hand.
In the aftermath of the horrific mass shooting of children at Sandy Hook, so many different ideas were considered in order to try to stem the danger to children in our schools – to try and keep our children out of reach of gun violence. Some may consider it impossible to build a creative and carefree learning environment while having in place protections against the dangers of violent perpetrators who can lash out without warning. Hopefully there is an answer out there.
The NRA proposed that having armed guards in our schools may have helped prevent the massacre of children at Sandy Hook. I discuss what I believe to be a better way.
There's no guarantee that armed security guards are going to do anything. Any time there is protection at an embassy or in a building, most of the time these guys are bored. Their guard is down. They're walking around having coffee, talking to their friends. It's human nature. You just can't be ever-vigilant. And again, if you're sitting out in front of a building, you're a sitting duck. In Newtown, you don't know if that guy Adam Lanza would have… if the first person he would have taken out would have been the guy he knows is the security guard. I think there's a better argument for keeping, like Air Marshalls, secretly-armed people at a school, so if somebody comes, then they can get shot by somebody they're not aware of is a security guard.
The debate obviously will continue, but it seems like the dialogue will become heated at every incident that comes along where the issues of guns and gun violence comes to the surface with another headline grabbing event. Perhaps if we continued this conversation between the news headlines, we would be better able to come to a solution that fits the neeeds of safety, security and gun rights that could be acceptible to all sides.
I recently had a chance to join a roundtable discussion with author Sam Harris, co-founder and CEO of Project Reason. It was entitled Self-Defense and the Law and it brought to light some very interesting subject matter on the various defense aspects involved in self-defense legal cases. I'll include some of what was discussed and how issues of law can vary depending on circumstances.
When asked 'what's the worst that can happen in a case of self-defense', I often tell others it can be much more than you imagine.
What does that mean?
Well, in spite of your claim of self-defense, you may go to prison for the rest of your life, especially if you kill somebody. In California, even if you have a valid self-defense claim, the DA’s office will typically still file charges on you.
I recently had a client, a 50-year-old nurse, who was in her own home when her ex-boyfriend (for 26 years) came over. He’d moved out 7 months earlier. There was a small history of domestic violence. But in fact, he had recently assaulted their 22-year-old daughter by head-butting her. While they were discussing things downstairs in the living room, he picked up a sledgehammer. She grew worried, told him to leave, and retreated upstairs. He put down the hammer but followed her upstairs and told her he did not have to leave.
Once upstairs, he was yelling at her. Finally, she grabbed her gun. She’s a cancer survivor. She’s had a double mastectomy. She’s half his size, and she told him to leave. He went for the gun, and she shot him. The bullet went through his rib cage and he died. She tried to save him by doing CPR.
The jury convicted her of murder despite the fact that she said that she was scared for her life.
Again, the general principle is correct as far as the law is concerned: You can defend yourself as long as you’re scared of great bodily injury—and that’s not such a high standard. Great bodily injury could be pretty much anything. I was just at a preliminary hearing the other day where the complaining witness had been hit and received two bruises under the eye. This qualified as great bodily injury.
Case In Point:
Every case can obviously vary, but there is no way to predict how the legal system will determine the outcome in your case.
For example, I just had a case where a bouncer was being a jerk to my client, a professional athlete, and would not let him into an after party, despite the fact that he had the proper wristband. The bouncer yanked on the wristband and chest-bumped him. My client took a swing and hit the bouncer in the nose, fracturing it—a lucky punch. My guy is 5′ 7″ and 160; the bouncer was 6′ 2″ and 225. He and two other guys beat the crap out of my client and choked him out; I even had pictures. So listen, if my guy hit him in the cheek, it would have been filed as a misdemeanor, with a five-day jail offer; instead, it was filed as a felony strike case, and the original offer was two years in state prison. My guy had NO record and was shitting a brick for almost a year. I took the case over from another lawyer, and eventually got the offer down to a year, which was still ridiculous, and eventually I was able to get him a misdemeanor with no jail time but lots of community service and restitution.
So here is a situation where my guy was NOT the initial aggressor, but his punch was deemed inappropriate by the DA’s Office, and because the guy had a broken nose, despite the fact that afterwards three guys beat my client, they initially wanted state prison! This is what I deal with all the time.
A Scenario:
Now, when asked about a certain scenario, things can change. For instance, let's say we are talking about a robbery.
If you’re being robbed, you can just kill the other person. Let me repeat that as it bears repeating. If you’re being robbed, you can take out your gun and shoot the person dead, and no one will prosecute you.
So why the differences in 'self-defense' in a robbery versus an altercation?
The difference is, it’s clear: You are the victim of a crime. And people know that robberies often result in death. I don’t care if the assailant just has his finger under his shirt.
To further this, if someone walks into a store where I am, and pulls a gun, (telling everyone to get down) – even if I can safely run away, I can legally intervene. Yes. Once somebody is engaged in felonious conduct, you can do whatever you do to stop him. So the difference between someone issuing a threat of violence versus an order to 'give me your wallet' can make the difference in a self-defense case.
A tougher question is, let’s say you’re walking down the street and you come upon a fight: One guy is pummeling another guy to the point where people are shouting, “Stop, stop, you’re going to kill him.” You might decide to take out your gun and shoot him just to save the other person’s life. But I’m not sure it’s going to go well for you in court.
You do not know anything about how the fight started, whether a weapon had already been used, or even whether the person being beaten was the initial aggressor — you don’t know anything. That’s the problem. It’s better to try and break it up, as opposed to killing somebody. Again, most scenarios of this kind don’t have easy answers. But robbery is clear-cut.
The
worst that can happen is that you go to prison for the rest of your
life, especially if you kill somebody. In California, even if you have a
valid self-defense claim, the DA’s office will typically still file
charges on you. I recently had a client, a 50-year-old nurse, who was in
her own home when her ex-boyfriend (for 26 years) came over. He’d moved
out 7 months earlier. There was a small history of domestic violence.
But in fact, he had recently assaulted their 22-year-old daughter by
head-butting her. While they were discussing things downstairs in the
living room, he picked up a sledgehammer. She grew worried, told him to
leave, and retreated upstairs. He put down the hammer but followed her
upstairs and told her he did not have to leave. Once upstairs, he was
yelling at her. Finally, she grabbed her gun. She’s a cancer survivor.
She’s had a double mastectomy. She’s half his size, and she told him to
leave. He went for the gun, and she shot him. The bullet went through
his rib cage and he died. She tried to save him by doing CPR.
The jury convicted her of murder despite the fact that she said that she
was scared for her life. Again, the general principle is correct as far
as the law is concerned: You can defend yourself as long as you’re
scared of great bodily injury—and that’s not such a high standard. Great
bodily injury could be pretty much anything. - See more at:
http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/self-defense-and-the-law#sthash.pAlfp1Sf.dpuf
On November 6, California voters passed the Three Strikes Reform Act. If you are currently charged with a California Penal Code offense, the new law provides that if you have two or more "Strikes," which are prior convictions for "Serious" or "Violent" felonies (as defined in the California Penal Code), you CANNOT receive a Three Strikes 25-years-to-life sentence unless the current felony is also a "Serious" or "Violent" felony.
That is the general rule for current cases, and there are exceptions. For example, if your prior conviction is for certain type of sex offenses, you may not be eligible for relief under this act. Also, if you current offense is a drug offense with a weight enhancement, even though it is not a Strike offense, you may also be sentenced as a Third Striker.
I have a great deal of experience in these matters, and I will be able to explain to you, if you are charged with a new crime and have two or more “Three Strike” prior convictions, how the new law will affect you.
Inmates in Custody
Most importantly, there are thousands of inmates in State Prison currently serving Three Strikes, 25 years-to-life sentences, where they had two or more prior Strike offenses, but the offense for which they were convicted was not a Strike offense. All of these inmates are eligible to petition the court to get released. However, the Three Strike Reform Act treats these inmates differently – in these cases, the court still has the discretion to keep the inmate in custody, if "in its discretion, determines that resentencing the inmate would pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety."
To that end, the court is to consider the inmate's criminal conviction history, including the types of crime committed, injury to the victims, the length of the prior prison commitment, remoteness, the inmate disciplinary record while in prison, his record of rehabilitation, and any other evidence the court sees as relevant.
in other words, it is very import to choose a great lawyer, dedicated to getting the inmate released from custody, as it is a labor intensive and complicated process, as a slew of materials must be gathered that put the inmate in the best possible light before the court, including support letters, old police reports, and prison records.
As this is the last and only chance to get the inmate out from under a Three Strikes life sentence, I will take the time to meet with family members and explain the process, and I will meet with the inmate in State Prison, to expedite the process, and get the case before the court at the earliest opportunity.
You lost in the state appellate court. Most likely it was an appeal from a court or jury trial. You have but one option left - a petition for review to the California Supreme Court. You are anxious because Supreme Court review is discretionary, and the Court accepts only a fraction of the petitions it receives. You want to maximize your chances of getting your petition granted, because a denial means your case is effectively over.
I am a former state Supreme Court staff attorney, and I have read and reviewed thousands of petitions. I will lay out the nuts and bolts of the petition for review, tell you what happens after it arrives in the Court, and give you some basic tips for good petition writing. I hope to give you insight into how to differentiate your petition from the thousands of petitions the Court receives annually.
With the exception of death penalty cases, review of cases by the Supreme Court is a matter of discretion. California Rule of Court 8.500(b)(1) states the primary ground for Supreme Court review: "When necessary to secure uniformity of decisions or to settle an important question of law." What does that phrase mean for you as the petition writer? Here is the two-part short answer: The Court is keen to accept a case where there is a published, and to a lesser extent, unpublished conflict in the state appellate court; and/or the case presents an issue of "statewide importance."
Rule 8.504 governs the content of your petition. For example, the petition must contain a nonargumentative statement of the issues; state why the case is significant under Rule 8.500(b); and state whether a petition for rehearing was filed in the appellate court and, if so, how the court ruled.
The petition must not exceed 8,400 words; if it does, you must make an application to the chief justice for a longer petition. The tables required by Rule 8.204(a)(1) and 8.204(b)(10) do not count against word length, and you may attach an exhibit you consider "unusually significant" and/or a relevant statute "not readily accessible," but such attachments cannot exceed 10 pages.
Finally, under Rule 8.500(c), the Supreme Court normally will only consider an issue timely raised in the appellate court; and will only accept the appellate court's statement of facts unless the petitioner has called attention to any alleged misstatement of an issue or fact in a rehearing petition.
In getting your case heard, first impressions count.
When a petition for review is received, it is scheduled for conference, and the central staff prepares a conference memorandum: civil petitions are sent to the director of the civil central staff, and are assigned to one of its 15 attorneys; criminal petitions are sent to the director of the criminal central staff and are assigned to one of its 20 attorneys.
The central staff's conference memorandum is designed to assist the Court in determining whether a case is appropriate for review. The memorandum summarizes the case's facts, procedural history, parties' arguments, and merits, and most importantly, the author of the memorandum makes a recommendation to the justices as to whether the case is sufficiently important for Court review.
This last function is vital because the central staff author's recommendation dictates the level of scrutiny the petition will receive at the justices' weekly Wednesday conference. Specifically, the conference memorandum's author assigns the case to either the "A" list or "B" list. While the Court may review up to 250 cases per week, only 20-30 cases will be on the "A" list. Cases assigned to the "B" list concern routine matters, or the application of settled law, and rarely, if ever, are accepted for review. The Court processes over 6,000 petitions for review annually, and authors approximately 110-120 opinions per year. Only one "B" list case was accepted for review in my three years on the Court.
An "A" list conference memorandum will generally have one of the following designations: "grant"; "grant and hold"; "grant and transfer"; "deny"; "submitted"; "denial submitted"; and "deny and depublish." The designation "submitted" indicates the central staff attorney believes the petition warrants special consideration. "Denial submitted" indicates the central staff attorney believes the petition should be denied, but still warrants special consideration Regarding depublication, the recent Court trend is to utilize the depublication option only in unusual circumstances.
Conference memoranda are distributed one week prior to the conference, and the chief of staff of each chamber divides the memoranda among staff attorneys. Each associate justice has five staff attorneys; the chief justice has seven. Staff attorneys are typically seasoned appellate attorneys who have been with their particular justice for several years. Only the justices attend the weekly conference. Four justices must agree in order for a case to be accepted for review. However, where three justices vote for a case to be accepted, often a fourth justice will join the three to ensure the case is accepted.
After a case is accepted, the chief justice assigns it to one of the justices who voted to grant review. That justice then prepares within the Court a "calendar memorandum," which is essentially a draft opinion. The calendar memorandum is distributed to the other justices who prepare a "preliminary response," indicating whether they concur, concur with reservations, are doubtful, or dissent. Preliminary responses typically suggest changes to the calendar memorandum, and the response may be as simple as a one-word "concur," or be as long as the calendar memorandum itself. The responding justice will also indicate whether he or she is intending to author a separate opinion.
Once all the preliminary responses are received, the authoring justice decides whether to incorporate any of the suggested changes into a revised calendar memorandum. If the revised calendar receives a majority of concurrences, it is scheduled for oral argument. If not, and the author is unwilling to accommodate the majority, the chief justice resets the matter or reassigns it to a dissenting justice. If the case is reassigned, once the new justice prepares a calendar memorandum and obtains a majority, the case is set for oral argument. The Court hears oral argument during the first week of each month from September through June. Each side has 30 minutes to present its case. In death penalty cases, oral argument may be extended to 45 minutes.
After oral argument, the case is discussed at the Court's private conference, and if a majority of the justices still agree with the recommendation of the justice who authored the calendar memorandum, that justice drafts a proposed majority opinion. In the rare event the majority view is now contrary to that of the calendar memorandum, the authoring justice must make changes reflecting the views of the new majority or the case is reassigned. This too happened only once in my three years on the Court.
In getting your case heard, first impressions count. Remember, given the gatekeeping function the central staff attorneys perform, you are writing to one attorney who will review your petition and assign it an "A" or "B" grade. That attorney brings his or her personality, skills, strengths, and weaknesses to your petition. You will never know that attorney's identity, but know this - you must differentiate your petition from the dozens of others he or she reviews weekly, which is best accomplished by presenting a compelling "Question Presented," and a compelling statement explaining why your matter is worthy of review. Once you have grabbed the staff attorney's attention, a concise statement of facts along with a well organized and reasoned legal discussion finishes the job. The best petitions for review rarely approach the 8,400 word limit. You must get on the "A" list to get any traction.
There is no magic formula that can assure your case will be accepted for review. Most cases do not blaze a new law trail, result in appellate court conflict, or present issues of statewide importance. But if your case has a chance, you now know how your matter will be treated, the hoops it will go through, and you have some basic tips for maximizing your chances of success.
Did you know that as a victim of crime, you have rights?
Did you know that with certain crimes you are entitled to know all court dates, and are entitled to have input into case settlement decisions?? Did you know that with certain assaultive crimes, you do not have to cooperate at all?
Did you know that as a victim of crime who has suffered economic loss, you are entitled victim restitution -- a money judgment against the defendant that is not dischargeable in bankruptcy?
Marsy's Law, or the Victim's Bill of Rights, gives victims many rights -- rights most people don't know about, but should know about -- that knowledge puts you, the victim, in a position of awareness and allows you to stay on top of what is likely a very difficult situation.
And as a victim, your goals may be different than the prosecutor's goals, or the defense attorney's goals; you may have you own ideas on what should be done and because of Marsy's Law you now have the right to be heard. In fact, you may be surprised to know that California has an agency that deals solely with claims
made by victims for money due to injuries suffered as a result of
criminal conduct.
Witnesses have rights, too, and your goals as a witness to a crime too may be different that the prosecutor's or defense attorney's goals in your case.
As a former prosecutor and now defense attorney, I can definitely tell you that if you want to be truly heard, it is better to have your own attorney speak for you, as your point of view will be taken very seriously.
And becasue of my background and training, I see the issues from both sides, and am uniquely able to help you in this time of need -- whether it is handling a subpoena, being heard as to a plea bargain, or getting the maximum amount of money you are entitled to under California law.
Did you know that if a politician embezzles even $1.00 that it is a
felony that can be prosecuted years later as there is no statute of
limitations?
Yes, you read that right. Stealing even a single dollar can be a felony. Of course you are probably saying to yourself, 'that has got to be impossible... how on earth could it possibly be true?'
It's quite simple: Political Corruption.
Pretty amazing actually, but anyone who is charged in crimes of political corruption need to know the facts when it comes to issues the very significant issues involved – including possible sentences mandated for such crimes. There are a few other things that also make crimes of Political Corruption particularly ominous too.
Many people involved in crimes of political corruption do not know that the charges leveled against them are likely to be very serious and often mandate that jail time be served in state prison? They also likely do not know that these cases are vertically prosecuted by a staff of prosecutors who specialize in such cases, and are very good at it.
Of course some of the more important issues involved in such cases require legal specialists who are familiar in this territory and represent clients who have been accused of various forms of political corruption. Someone who knows the rules and how they apply, be it embezzlement or other political crimes.
Many people do not know that even before you speak to law enforcement in the investigatory phase, you have the right to a lawyer and should contact one – before you ever speak to anyone.
Did you know that it is often better to address the issues head on with an attorney and not wait as it will put you in a stronger legal position?
I represent several local politicians who have been accused of crimes against the public trust, such as embezzlement of public funds, misappropriation, fraud, and violation of election laws. These cases are complicated, as they are accompanied by thousands of pages of documents, and require diligence, resourcefulness, and an ability to spot hidden weaknesses in the case. As a former prosecutor and Supreme Court staff attorney, I am uniquely suited to help you in these cases.
If you are being investigated by the Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office, or another law enforcement arm of the State, or you have been charged, you need to know your legal options, and you need to have the best representation possible, and you need to do it now.
If you have been
arrested for a misdemeanor or felony (other than DUI), the first piece of
advice I have is this. DO NOT TALK TO THE POLICE! It never helps. They
seek only to get incriminating information. Your natural inclination is
to talk. DON'T.
You will be given bail and the right to make a phone
call. Call your lawyer to arrange bail. Lawyers typically work with
reputable bail bondsmen. Your family will not make such a wise choice,
and the next thing you know, the bail bondsman owns your mother's home.
It is better to have a lawyer arrange bail than you yourself or your
family. Your lawyer will likely get a better rate, and you personally
will get better service. The bail bond company I work with is top-notch
and open 24 hours a day, every day.
If you are charged with a
misdemeanor or felony, it is best to hire a lawyer. There may be
immigration consequences if you are a non-citizen, and typically you
will get a better result if you have a lawyer fighting for your rights.
Each case is different because each fact pattern is different. I
offer a free consultation and will help you make the right choice.
Men who have been arrested for a sex crime, whether it is
statutory rape, date rape, sexual battery, or forcible rape, will face
aggressive prosecution from law enforcement and district attorneys. All
sex crime charges are taken very seriously by the State of California,
especially if the sexual offense involved a victim who was under 18
years old. If the victim is under 14 years old, you are in very serious
trouble and are likely looking at life in prison.
If you are accused of
a sex crime, it is important that you immediately speak with an
experienced criminal defense attorney. Even if you are innocent, you
will need advice and direction from a lawyer who has successfully
represented clients who have been accused of a sex crime. Without such
guidance, you will have a difficult time contesting the criminal
charges.
Sex crime cases demand an extensive evaluation of the facts,
in-depth interviews of the accuser and witnesses, analysis of forensic
evidence, and complicated stereotypes must be addressed. Men especially
are behind the eight-ball when charged with a sex crime. With the help
of an experienced attorney, you stand a better chance of fighting your
charges both in and out of court.
Ok, you've been pulled over by a police officer and you have
been drinking. What do you do? This is a tough question, and different
lawyers will give you different answers.
In
California, there are two things the State must prove to convict someone
of a DUI. It must prove that you were driving and that you were driving
under the influence of alcohol or drugs. You cannot legally drive in
California if your blood-alcohol concentration (BAC) exceeds 0.08% or if
you are under the influence of drugs, or a combination of the two. If
you are involved in the situation where proof of YOU driving is an
issue (such as where a police officer rolls up after an accident), be
cooperative but NEVER admit driving.
More common is the situation where
the officer sees you driving and you are pulled over. At the point you
are pulled over, you are NOT under arrest, so your "Miranda" right to
remain silent does not apply. Instead, the officer has every right to
ask you questions as part of his ongoing investigation. Every police
report will state you have bloodshot and watery eyes, the smell of
alcohol on your breath, and slurred speech - which the officer will
observe before you even get out of the car. More likely than not, the
officer will also have observed bad driving. Frankly, he has already
decided to arrest you, but he is still entitled to ask you questions and
perform field sobriety tests (FSTs) at the scene.
Here is a tip: keep
strong-flavored foil wrapped gum (that pops out) within easy access; it
may or may not mask your breath, and it can't hurt to try to take away
one of the symptoms of drinking.
BETTER TIP: Go online and buy a
portable breath tester (ALCOHAWK) and keep it in your car. They cost
between $40.00 - $100.00 depending on the model, but could save you
THOUSANDS of dollars and even time in prison. I have told this to
hundreds of people: drinking and driving is the only way normally good
people wind up in prison.
Think about it, if you drink, drive and kill
someone, you will go to state prison, and maybe for the rest of your
life. It happens all the time and, sadly, California state prisons are
filled with drunk drivers. It is better to BUY A PORTABLE BREATH TESTER
and test yourself before driving; if you are over the limit DON'T
DRIVE.
Getting back to the more common scenario, just getting pulled
over after drinking, the key question from the officer you will have to
answer is "have you been drinking?" It is likely a no-win situation. If
you admit to drinking, whether it is "Officer, I had one, two or three
drinks," the officer will assume you have had more. If you have had a
few and admit to "no drinking," but smell like a liquor store, the
officer will assume you are a liar. But if you truly think you are under
the limit, and are confident that there is no discernible odor of
alcohol on your breath, my advice is not to admit to drinking as that
answer is the lesser of two evils. Here is a CHP drink chart guide that
will allow you to better judge whether or not you are over or under the
limit:
These are rough estimates. AND REMEMBER THE
FOLLOWING: martinis and mixed drinks, if free-poured, typically contain
much more than 1.25 oz. of alcohol, so one martini with 3 oz. can put
you over the limit; this chart assumes 1.25 oz of 80-proof liquor per
drink. The chart also assumes 12 oz. 3.5% alcohol beers (think Budweiser
or Coors), but ice beer (5.5%), malt liquor (7.0%), and certain
specialty beers (9.0%) are stronger, so it will take fewer beers to put
you over the limit; 16 and 20 oz. "pints" will also! And a typical wine
glass pour is 6 oz. not 4 oz. as assumed in the chart. Be
careful!!!!!!!!
In any event, whether or not you admit drinking, the
officer will certainly follow up with FSTs. Put differently, if he asks
you out of the car to do FSTs, you are likely going to be
arrested.
There is no law that requires you to perform FSTs. However,
if you refuse, you will surely go to jail. It takes a lot of nerve to
refuse FSTs. If you are not that type of person, do the best you can. No
matter how good you think you did, the police report will indicate that
you could not follow directions and were unsteady.
WARNING: There
is a portable breath test administered by the officer in the field
called the PAS (Preliminary Alcohol Screening) test - you simply blow
into a portable device at the scene. If you have been drinking, DO NOT
AGREE TO TAKE THIS TEST. You have that choice in California. Just
explain that you are happy to take a breath test at the station. This
will likely piss off the officer, but he is not your friend anyway. But
taking this test may preclude your attorney from asserting certain
defenses for you at both the DMV hearing and at trial.
At the station,
they will offer the choice of a breath or blood test. My advice is to
take the breath test because it is less accurate than the blood test.
However, some attorneys prefer that you submit to a blood test because
it prevents the officer from knowing your blood alcohol level prior to
writing the police report.
If you REFUSE to take either test, DMV will
suspend your license for one year, pretty much a slam dunk. Refusing to
take the test may or may not help you beat your case if you go to court.
"May not" is the more likely scenario, so take the breath or blood
test. However, if you are facing a second or third DUI, you may
want to politely refuse any test.
Once you have been arrested and
booked, you will be released. Two separate proceedings will be filed
against you: an administrative proceeding (by DMV) and a legal
proceeding (the court case). You should seek legal counsel right away,
but if not, you must deal with the DMV aspect of your case immediately,
because you have only 10 days to call the DMV Driver Safety Office to
set up a hearing (there are 3 in Los Angeles County -- in Commerce, El
Segundo and Van Nuys), or that right is lost and your license will be
suspended. While it is not easy to win at a DMV hearing, good lawyers do
win all the time.
For a first time DUI, DMV will suspend your license
for 4 months, so it is better to win than take the bus, drive illegally
or rely on friends. Get an experienced criminal defense attorney for
your DMV hearing.
Next is the actual court case. Two things will
happen: you will get an offer to a reduced charge, or you will not get
an offer to a reduced charge. If it is the latter, you have to decide
whether to go to trial or plea guilty or no contest to the charge. That
decision is dependent on too many variables to fully discuss here, but
here are a few for you to consider: (1) whether there was an illegal
stop - a driver cannot be stopped unless the officer has a reasonable
and articulate basis to believe that a traffic law has been violated;
(2) the FSTs can be attacked, whether because you have heath problems,
there was bad weather, or bad administration of the tests themselves;
(3) the breath test can be challenged on several bases - bad test, bad
machine, bad administration of the test; and a good DUI scientific
expert can refute many of the claims made by law enforcement regarding
your BAC; (5) the police officer may be a bad witness; (6) two police
officers may contradict each other; or (7) you have witnesses who can
credibly testify on your behalf. This list is not exhaustive.
Again,
talk to your attorney and he or she will lay out all of you options. If
you do not have a criminal defense attorney, I am available for a free
consultation.